Homemade Sloppy Joe Recipe (turkey or beef)

A traditional favorite, this easy turkey sloppy Joe recipe is made with ground turkey (or beef, if you prefer), and lots of veggies for a healthier sandwich!

A zesty mixture of ground turkey (or beef), bell peppers, and onions with an easy ketchup-based sauce, this sloppy Joe recipe is tasty and always hits the spot. It’s great for weeknight dinners or for casual get-togethers.

This recipe for turkey sloppy Joes definitely fits into the “go-to” category in my house. It’s easy, and I almost always have all the ingredients in my pantry and fridge.

Why buy a can of Manwich when you can make homemade sloppy Joes? The sauce beats Manwich by a long shot! Much more flavorful, more economical, and lots better for you! Even with Manwich, you still have to brown the meat. It’s not much more difficult to make your own healthy sauce to go with it.

On weeks when I am slacking on my meal planning (this happens often), you’ll find me picking up a package of ground turkey at the store. It usually ends up in spaghetti with meat sauce, these sloppy Joe sandwiches, or tacos. If you’re looking for really, really easy sloppy Joes, check out this recipe with only 5 ingredients, including the bun and a slice of cheese!

Some of you may remember the old fashioned sloppy Joes from the 50’s. My mom talks about the “barbecues” that were served in school lunches made with canned chicken gumbo soup and lots of greasy ground beef. Oh my, I just looked it up and that recipe is still on Campbell’s website!

About This Sloppy Joe Recipe

Why ground turkey instead of beef? I just try to cut down on fat and calories whenever possible, and using ground turkey instead of beef is an easy way to accomplish that. It’s hard to tell the difference in these sloppy Joes. If I’m making a large batch, sometimes I use half turkey and half beef.

The bell peppers and onions in this sloppy joe recipe not only add flavor, they also add a lot of good nutrition and fiber. They help to stretch your meat budget too. It’s always good to eat more veggies and less meat!

The sauce is pretty basic, easy to make with ingredients that you have on hand. It shouldn’t take you more than fifteen minutes to throw it together and the mixture can simmer on the stove indefinitely. Just give it a stir now and then to make sure it isn’t sticking. It’s ready when you are.

I’ll run you through the recipe here to get you started and give you a few extra tips.

As always, you’ll find the printable recipe card near the end of the post, with complete instructions and nutrition information.

What You’ll Need

• Ground Turkey or Beef: It’s really up to you which one you choose. Sometimes I even use a mixture of the two especially if I’m making it for a crowd. Choose a leaner cut of beef, such as ground round to cut down on grease.
• Onion: A regular yellow cooking onion is fine for this recipe but other types of onion are good, too, such as red onion or sweet white onion.
• Bell Peppers: Just for visual appeal, I choose a couple different colors. You’ll need about one total pepper so if you’d rather just use one color, that’s perfectly fine.
• Ketchup: Choose a ketchup with no high fructose corn syrup. I realize that ketchup is a processed food that often contains high amounts of sugar but there are brands that offer a better choice. If you prefer, make it with tomato sauce (an 8 oz. can). You may have to increase the seasonings a bit.
• Dark Brown Sugar: Just a tablespoon of sugar gives the sauce the tangy sweet and sour flavor. Light brown sugar is fine, too, or a tablespoon of molasses.
• Yellow Mustard, Worcestershire Sauce, Garlic Powder: This trio of familiar pantry items flavors the sauce. Feel free to vary it to your taste. My mom always adds a splash of vinegar because she likes things tangy.
• Buns: Hamburger buns or slider buns are commonly used for a sloppy Joe sandwich but any type of bread, roll, or sub bun can be used. Toasting them first really adds a nice touch.
• Optional Toppings: Sloppy Joes are perfectly good just the way they are but why not jazz them up with a few toppings? Try shredded or sliced cheese, shredded lettuce, a spoonful of coleslaw, a slice of tomato, sliced avocado, chopped onions, whatever you like. Pickles are great too: spicy Korean pickles, refrigerator dill pickles, or pickled red onions. My husband slathers his sandwich with yellow mustard, so hey, anything goes!

How To Make This Recipe

Begin by chopping the onions and peppers. Sometimes I throw the sauce ingredients in a measuring cup before I start cooking so it’s all ready to add in, but you can also add them in separately.

Choose a skillet that will easily accommodate the ingredients. If you plan on simmering the sloppy Joes for an extended time, a cover is a good idea.

Add the ground meat, chopped onions, and peppers to the pan. Season with salt and pepper and cook over medium high heat, stirring and breaking up the chunks of ground meat. I like to use a wooden spatula with a flat edge.

Once the meat is cooked and the vegetables are softened, add the sauce ingredients, stirring well to coat. Turn the heat down to low and simmer the mixture for thirty minutes or so.

If you’re in a hurry, no problem. The sloppy Joes can be eaten as soon as the mixture is good and hot. It tastes a bit better as it simmers awhile though so if you have time, let it cook for a bit so the flavors can meld together. In fact, it will be fine for an hour or more and you can even throw it in a slow cooker, set it on Low, and leave it for a few hours.

Serve on buns with toppings, if desired. These air fryer French fries are a super good side, or if you prefer, air fryer tater tots or air fryer sweet potato fries. A simple green salad and potato chips are perfect, too, especially with homemade French onion dip! Really, almost anything goes with sloppy Joes, from roasted broccoli to a bowl of creamy squash soup.

FAQs

Make It Your Own

• I like to make this mix heavy on the vegetables, but if that isn’t your cup of tea, start with 1/4 cup of green peppers and 1/4 cup of onions. I put in over a cup of mixed bell peppers, and a heaping half cup of onions.
• Want it even chunkier? Add diced tomatoes as well as peppers and onions.
• Spice it up with red pepper flakes or ground cayenne pepper.
• Substitute an 8 oz. can of tomato sauce for the ketchup. Increase seasonings to taste. Ketchup has a lot of sugar, so you might want to add more brown sugar. It also has a vinegary tang, so you may want to consider adding a splash of white vinegar. A teaspoon or two should be plenty.
• Looking for burgers instead? Try turkey burgers, pizza burgers, or air fryer burgers.

Make-Ahead Ideas

Turkey sloppy Joes are perfect for make ahead meals. Prepare a double or triple batch of this sloppy Joe mix and freeze it in serving size containers. It will keep for a few months.

Another idea: Make a big batch in the morning and let it simmer in the slow cooker until you’re ready to serve.

Great for get-togethers or tail-gate parties! Just have lots of sliced buns and some toppings for make-your-own sandwiches.

Storage & Reheating Tips

Leftover sloppy Joe mixture can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 4 days if refrigerated promptly in a covered container. It can be frozen for up to three months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before reheating.

It can be reheated on the stove over medium heat until warmed through or in the microwave in 30-second increments.

Leftover Love

It’s easy to repurpose leftover sloppy Joe mixture. Make baked macaroni and cheese, topping it with sloppy Joe meat before baking. Add some taco seasoning and make burritos or tacos. Top a pizza crust with sloppy Joe mix, add shredded cheese and sliced peppers and onions and bake.

More hot sandwich Recipes

• Turkey sliders, aka Rachel sandwiches
• Chicken Sandwich with Bacon, Leeks and Gouda
• Pizza Panini Sandwiches
• Crockpot Buffalo Chicken Sandwiches
• The Best Meatball Subs
• Pepperoni Pizza Sliders 
• Ham and Swiss Sliders 
• Turkey and Cheese Crescent Rolls