Vegetarian Stuffed Peppers – Southwestern

Colorful Stuffed Peppers

Eating these vegetarian stuffed peppers won’t leave you feeling stuffed and lethargic. They’re packed with a tasty, slightly spicy filling that is bright and flavorful, reminiscent of summer and good for you. Along with rice and cheese, you’ll find tender golden corn, chewy pinto beans, red tomatoes, and bright green cilantro, all packaged in a colorful bell pepper shell.

How To Make Stuffed Peppers

Vegetarian stuffed peppers are a snap to make, especially if you happen to have leftover rice. I like to cut the peppers in half, top to bottom and stuff the halves, rather than stuff the whole peppers. Halves are easier to fill and you can really pile in the stuffing, mounding it up, and topping it all with a little sprinkle of extra cheese.

Prepare the peppers. Blanch the pepper halves first. If you’re not familiar with the term “blanch”, it simply means boil briefly or scald, and then drain. Blanching gets the cooking process started for the peppers so they are nice and tender when you serve them.

Drain the blanched peppers on a wire rack or paper towels, cut side down, so you don’t have a bunch of water pooled inside.

Make the stuffing. Mix together white or brown cooked rice, pinto beans (black beans are good, too), canned corn, canned tomatoes, canned green chiles, shredded Monterey Jack cheese, fresh green onions, and fresh cilantro. Season with cumin, chili powder, and salt and pepper as needed. 

Fill the pepper halves. Pile the filling into the drained pepper halves, putting them into a baking dish as you go. Sprinkle a little (or a lot) more cheese on top.

Bake. Pop the stuffed peppers in the oven for 40 minutes until they’re piping hot. So so good!

Recipe Variations

• Substitute a different grain. Brown rice can be substituted for white rice, but also consider couscous, quinoa, orzo, or bulgur (cracked wheat).
• Use different veggies or beans in the stuffing. Black beans are great! You don’t care for corn? Just leave it out. 
• Stuff poblano peppers. Poblanos have a little more kick than bell peppers. Look for large poblano peppers that will be able to hold stuffing.
• Make a casserole instead. Skip stuffing the peppers, and put the filling into a greased casserole dish and bake it. You could also do this with any filling that didn’t fit into the peppers. 
• Add meat. Add ground beef or turkey or try this pepper casserole that mimics stuffed peppers and includes ground turkey. Prep is a little easier, too.
• Make it Italian! Try pepperoni pizza stuffed peppers.
• Don’t care for peppers? Try stuffed butternut squash or stuffed portobello mushrooms.

What To Serve with Stuffed Peppers

Sides. Vegetarian stuffed peppers contain a protein, grain, and vegetable, making them a pretty complete meal by themselves. If you would like to serve a side dish with them, try oven roasted sweet potatoes. Fresh fruit is great, too, especially a colorful citrus salad. 

Toppings. I would be remiss if I didn’t mention possible toppings for these vegetarian stuffed peppers. I love a dollop of sour cream, or a delicious cilantro lime drizzle. Salsa or salsa verde add a lot of flavor. Sliced avocado is wonderful, or additional green onions or cilantro. If you like a little spicy heat, top them with jalapeño slices.

As a side. Stuffed peppers are a satisfying meatless main dish but could be served as a side with tequila lime marinaded chicken or BBQ salmon.

Make-Ahead Ideas

Make them a day ahead. If you want to make the stuffed peppers a day ahead, prepare them but don’t bake them. Wrap the baking dish with your stuffed peppers in plastic wrap and place in the refrigerator. Bake as directed when you’re ready.

Freeze unbaked stuffed peppers. Simply wrap the dish well and place in freezer. Thaw the frozen peppers in the fridge a day ahead. When they’re thawed, bake them as directed. 

Storage & Reheating Tips

Store leftover peppers, well wrapped, in your refrigerator for up to 4 days. Leftover peppers are really good reheated, making them a perfect lunch the day after. Just microwave them until they are nice and hot, and enjoy.