Smashed Potatoes with Garlic Butter and Parmesan

You’re gonna love these potatoes! We can barely wait until the timer goes off before snatching these succulent little morsels right off the pan. Hot, hot, hot, but so, so good!  

Ingredients you’ll need

• Potatoes: Baby potatoes that are one to two inches in diameter
• Butter: Both unsalted and salted will work for this recipe.
• Garlic: We recommend fresh garlic for this recipe!
• Parsley: Again, fresh is best here because it gives a pop of freshness to an otherwise rich recipe.
• Parmesan Cheese: Because everything is better with cheese, right? Buy the pre-grated if you want to save some time. Pecorino would also be tasty.

How To Make crispy smashed potatoes

It’s a two step process. The potatoes need to be boiled before you can smash and bake them. It’d be pretty impossible to smash raw potatoes. You’d need a hammer or something and the results wouldn’t be pretty, although I guess it could be therapeutic if you were feeling hostile or frustrated. Just kidding. Sort of. 

Boil small whole potatoes for 15 to 20 minutes until they’re fork tender. Larger potatoes will take a little longer than small ones. Try not to cook the potatoes until they’re falling apart. Drain and cool slightly so you can handle them. 

Meanwhile, preheat your oven so it’s nice and hot. A hot oven equals crispy potatoes. 

Smash the potatoes. I’m not sure “smash” is really the right word to describe this process. It’s really more like squashing them flat. Use bottom of a heavy glass or jar, a potato masher, or the heel of your hand. Press down until the potatoes are flattened slightly. The skins will crack and split and the potatoes will be smushed. You don’t need to pound them (or maybe you do, depending on what kind of day you’re having). 

Make garlic butter. Melt butter, and mix in garlic, fresh parsley, cheese, salt, and pepper.

Roast them until they are crisp. Spread the potatoes on a sheet pan, brush them lovingly with the butter mixture (they just got smashed, after all!), sprinkle them with Paremesan, and roast them in the hot oven until they’re nice and golden, crispy on the bottom and delicious all the way through. 

What’s the difference between mashed potatoes and smashed potatoes?

Just one little letter “s”! That letter makes a world of difference in potatoes, though. Mashed potatoes are generally peeled, cooked, and mashed with a mixer, ricer, or masher and lots of butter and milk, until they are creamy and smooth. Smashed potatoes, on the other hand, are small potatoes that are smashed just once so that they are still whole but squashed flat, and baked to a crispy golden brown. 

Ways To Change Up Smashed Potatoes

Since there are only five ingredients in this recipe, not counting salt and pepper, changing any one of the ingredients will make your smashed potatoes uniquely your own. Here’s a few ideas to get you started:

• Use a different type of potato. Yukon gold, baby red, purple, fingerling, or any small potato will work and each variety has unique characteristics. For a low carb alternative, try smashed Brussels sprouts.
• Substitute olive oil for butter, or use a combination.
• Make it vegan. Omit the Parmesan cheese and use olive oil instead of butter.
• Experiment with garlic. I like minced garlic but you may prefer garlic powder and/or onion powder. Add as much as you like!
• Try different herbs. Minced fresh rosemary is fantastic, and so is sage. Add a pinch or two of herbes de provence, which is a blend of French style herbs.
• Add spices. Sprinkle the potatoes with a little chili powder, paprika, smoked paprika, or any spice blend you like. Try my Cajun seasoning or all purpose seasoning. My southwest spice blend is great for a Tex-Mex vibe.
• Looking for a one pan dinner? Try chicken thighs with smashed potatoes and green beans, roasted in the oven on just one sheet pan.

Make Ahead & Reheating Tips

Make ahead: Boil the potatoes a day ahead, cool, and refrigerate them. When you’re ready, proceed with the smashing and baking. 

Reheating: For maximum crispiness, smashed potatoes are best eaten right away. If you have leftovers or want to make them ahead, reheat the potatoes in your air fryer or toaster oven to crisp them back up. They’ll keep up to four days in the fridge.

More spuds!

Potatoes go with almost anything, for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. No wonder there are so many ways to prepare them! Here are a few more recipes that I’m sure you’ll love:

• Air Fryer Potatoes — crispy with hardly any oil!
• Stovetop Scalloped Potatoes (so easy!)
• Grilled Rosemary Potatoes
• The Best Potato Salad
• How to Make Baked Potatoes
• Instant Pot Mashed Potatoes —  the easiest way to make mashed potatoes!
• Garlic Roasted Potatoes with Paprika or Dill Roasted Potatoes with Lemon
• Roasted Fingerling Potatoes
• Brown Butter Slow Cooker Mashed Potatoes