Instant Pot Rice Pudding

Instant Pot rice pudding is warm, creamy, lightly sweetened, and so satisfying. It’s the perfect dessert on a cold winter evening.

 

Call me a pudding fan. There’s something about homemade pudding that really is so enticing. It’s like a cuddly blanket or a gentle hug. It’s sweet, but not too sweet, and so creamy. Pudding is a comforting dessert that makes me feel happy.

Homemade pudding is simple and unassuming. It doesn’t have any false pretenses. It is what it is. (I think I just used one of my dad’s favorite phrases right there. “It is what it is” seems to be applicable to a lot of subjects lately. Sometimes you just have to shrug and say, well, whatever.)

I have long been a fan of homemade vanilla pudding (I love the brown butter option!) and chocolate pudding isn’t far behind. In fact, it isn’t behind at all. What am I saying?! I love chocolate pudding!

Rice pudding brings back memories of my grandpa and his version of rice pudding. He simply prepared white rice with milk instead of water. He threw in a lot of raisins because he really loved raisins. We would spread the rice out on a plate, slather butter on it, and then sprinkle it with brown sugar and cinnamon. It was a special grandpa treat! You know, now I’m thinking that would be really great with coconut rice. Hmmm….

About This Recipe

Anyways, back to Instant Pot rice pudding. Stovetop recipes call for constant stirring as the rice cooks and absorbs the milk. The process is similar to making risotto and it takes a little patience and time.

Your Instant Pot simplifies the process drastically. It’s pretty much hands off until the very end when you stir for a couple of minutes. I’ve found that a pressure cooker really is the ticket for recipes that traditionally take a lot of stirring. Try Instant Pot risotto and Instant Pot polenta and you’ll see what I mean.

I’m going to get you started on the recipe here and give you a few helpful tips as we go. The recipe card below will give you specific measurements, instructions, and nutrition information.

What You’ll need

• Basmati Rice: This long grain white rice is the perfect choice for rice pudding. See more about rice in the FAQ section below.
• Milk: For the richest, creamiest pudding, use whole milk. Lower fat milk tends to separate. Since rice pudding is basically rice and milk, using the right milk is important.
• Brown Sugar: This rice pudding isn’t heavily sweetened, with only a half cup of sugar. Some recipes are made with sweetened condensed milk which makes a very sweet pudding.
• Heavy Cream or Half-and-Half: Either one is fine. Heavy cream makes a richer pudding but we found that half-and-half did the job just as well. In case you’re wondering, half-and-half is simply a 1:1 blend (hence the “half and half” name) of heavy cream and whole milk.
• Eggs: You’ll need 2 large eggs. It’s best if they are at room temperature before adding them to the pudding. Simply take them out of the fridge when you begin cooking the rice. By the time the rice is ready, the eggs will be warm enough.
• Vanilla: Pure vanilla extract or vanilla bean paste are both good choices. Vanilla bean paste adds a bit more sugar but it does have those tiny brown specks of vanilla bean that are really nice in rice pudding. Both products can be found in baking aisle, usually next to the spices.
• Nutmeg: Freshly grated nutmeg has the best flavor but ground nutmeg is perfectly acceptable.
• Raisins, optional: Traditionally, rice pudding is made with raisins. Any type of raisin is fine. If the raisins are super dried out, soak them in hot water ten to fifteen minutes to plump them up before adding them to the pudding. If you don’t care for raisins, feel free to leave them out.

How to make it

Get your Instant Pot out and let’s get cooking! Remove all the ingredients you’ll need from the refrigerator: milk, eggs, half-and-half. Although you won’t be using everything right away, it’s best if they come to room temperature while the rice is cooking.

If your raisins are not-quite-fresh and are looking a lot like dried pebbles, pour a cup of very hot water over them and let them plump up for a while. Be sure to drain them well before adding them to the rice pudding.

I like to lightly spray the inside of my Instant Pot with nonstick spray. It really helps when it comes to cleanup.

Measure out a cup of rice and add it to the Instant Pot, along with the water, a cup of milk, and a bit of salt. Lock on the lid and set the cooker to Pressure Cook for five minutes. Some models have different settings, such as Manual, High Pressure.

It will take about 10 to 11 minutes to come to pressure.

When the timer goes off, leave the cover on and wait for ten minutes. This is a natural release of pressure and means that you don’t do anything except maybe set a timer to keep track of the time.

Once ten minutes has elapsed, release the remaining pressure and carefully remove the lid. Stir in the brown sugar. The pudding won’t look much like pudding yet but don’t worry.

Whisk together the milk, cream, and eggs. Choose a mixing bowl that has a little extra room. Scoop out a half cup of the hot rice mixture from the Instant Pot and slowly add it to the egg mixture, whisking as you go. By warming up the egg mixture slowly, you avoid the risk of “scrambled eggs” when you add the eggs to the pudding.

Now, go ahead and slowly add the bowlful of milky eggs and rice to the rice mixture in the Instant Pot. Turn the Instant Pot on Sauté mode. Stirring constantly, bring the mixture to a simmer. Let the pudding cook for a few minutes as it begins to thicken.

Turn off the Instant Pot and stir in the raisins, vanilla, and nutmeg. At this point, the rice pudding will still look pretty thin. Don’t despair, it’s okay. Pour (or scoop) it into a large bowl to cool, or into individual serving dishes. Do be careful; the pudding is extremely hot.

Let the pudding cool for fifteen minutes or so before serving it. While it can be eaten either warm or cold, I really think it’s best warm. Enjoy! If you want to sprinkle a little cinnamon on top, that’s always nice, too.

FAQs

Make It Your Own

• If you prefer, long grain white rice or jasmine rice can be substituted for basmati rice.
• If you’d like to try a stovetop recipe, try my cranberry vanilla rice pudding. It’s a lovely shade of pink.
• Looking for a dairy-free, gluten-free, no egg recipe? Try vegan rice pudding from One Lovely Life.
• If you’re more into chia pudding than rice pudding, try my chia seed pudding, chocolate chia pudding, or chai chia pudding.

Storage Tips

Cool rice pudding for an hour or so at room temperature. Spread it out so it cools more quickly. Cover and refrigerate the pudding for up to three days. It doesn’t freeze well.

Rice pudding is best served warm. Because it tends to thicken as it sets, you’ll probably want to stir in a splash of milk or half-and-half. Warm individual portions in the microwave at medium power in 30 second increments, stirring each time.

Leftover Love

Enjoy leftover rice pudding for breakfast. Warm it up and top it with sliced bananas and a sprinkle of cinnamon, warm apple compote, or fresh berries.