Cream Cheese Filled Brownies

Let me begin with a bit of advice: Make these cream cheese filled brownies when you’re expecting company. Your guests will love them, and serving the brownies to company for dessert will prevent you from eating all of them.

These brownies are so good and it’s a huge temptation to eat way too many. Usually I like to send any extra goodies to work with my husband. His coworkers love me. But because these bars really should be refrigerated, they don’t go to work with him. At least that’s my story.

The true story? These layered brownies are good! I don’t really want to share.

Cream cheese filled brownies are only a teensy bit harder than boxed brownies. You can handle it, I have faith in you! And they are totally worth the effort.

About These Cream Cheese Filled Brownies

Better than cheesecake. I know, that’s a pretty wild claim but these brownies really are better than cheesecake, in my humble opinion. They’re a combination of two delicious desserts, brownies and cheesecake. How can you go wrong with that combination?

This is an easy recipe. I’ll run through the recipe here to get you started but I assure you, it’s pretty easy and starts with a purchased brownie mix. I like to keep things simple and there are some really great brownie mixes on the market! However, if you’d rather make your own brownies from scratch with cocoa powder, flour, butter, and so on, feel free.

Ingredient Notes

• Brownie Mix: Buy your favorite brand but make sure it’s the right size brownie mix. You need the family size which is 18.3 ounces and makes a 9 x13 inch pan of brownies. If you use a smaller sized mix, there won’t be enough brownie batter to cover the filling. Don’t be tempted to buy the jazzed up brownie mixes because you’re going to do the jazzing up yourself!
• Eggs, Oil, Water: Use the amounts listed on your brownie mix. There is some variation depending on which brand you buy.
• Espresso Powder: This ingredient is optional. It adds a nice mocha flavor to the batter but feel free to leave it out if you so desire or can’t find it at your market. I usually find it in the coffee aisle by the instant coffee.
• Mini Chocolate Chips: These little babies are added to the brownie batter AND the filling. Lots of chocolate goodness here! Mini chocolate chips work better than the regular sized chips because they disperse more evenly throughout the batter. If you only have regular sized chips, they will work.
• Cream Cheese: I usually choose reduced fat cream cheese. Full fat cream cheese is fine but don’t buy the non-fat. It has a bunch of extra fillers and stuff in it and we don’t want that in our brownies.
• Egg, Butter, Flour, Sugar, Vanilla: These make up the rest of the filling ingredients. Plus the additional mini chocolate chips!

How To Make These Brownies

Get ready. Turn the oven on to get it preheating and gather together everything you’ll need: all the ingredients, a 9 x 13 inch pan, an electric mixer and a couple of mixing bowls. Grease the pan by spraying it lightly with cooking spray.

Make the brownie mix. In one of the mixing bowls, combine the brownie mix with the eggs, oil, and water according to the package directions. If you’re using the espresso powder, it’s best to add that before you add the liquid ingredients. Make sure it’s blended well into the dry mix.

Don’t overmix the batter. Just stir it until the dry ingredients are blended with the wet. Fold in a cup of the mini chocolate chips

Put first layer in pan. Spread half the batter into the prepared pan. You don’t have to measure it so it’s exactly half, just take a guess. Don’t worry if it looks a little uneven. Just spread it out as well as you can.

Make the filling. In the other mixing bowl, combine the cream cheese, another egg, flour, sugar, and vanilla.

Use an electric mixer to blend it really well.

Fold in another half cup of chocolate chips.

Add cream cheese layer to pan. Spread the filling on the layer of batter in the pan. I usually spoon it on in plops and then kind of smooth it out. Again, don’t worry if it’s not exactly even. Try not to blend it into the bottom layer.

Add second layer of brownie batter. Spread the remaining brownie batter over the filling. It will look like it’s hardly enough but that’s okay. Once the brownies bake, they puff up and spread out. The layers aren’t super distinct and that’s just fine.

Bake. Put the pan into the preheated oven and bake until a toothpick inserted about two inches from the side comes out fairly clean. Why not test the brownies in the center? We’re looking for a certain amount of gooey-ness to our brownies. No one likes brownies that are dry, hard, and overdone.

Serve. Enjoy with a cup of coffee or hot tea. Sometimes I serve the brownies with this homemade ginger spiced hot chocolate. You can make it in the microwave.

For a spectacular dessert, top a brownie with a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream and a drizzle of homemade hot fudge sauce.

More Brownie Recipes

Not crazy about cream cheese? I have lots more brownies for you! I’m sure you’re going to find at least a few recipes you love.

• Buckeye Brownies
• Kahlua Brownies with Cinnamon
• Mocha Brownies (easy recipe!)
• Black Bean Brownies – no one will ever know!
• Brownie Waffles – Brownies in 3 minutes. Yeah!

Make Ahead Ideas

If you’d like to get a little jump start on making these cream cheese filled brownies, make the filling up to a day ahead and refrigerate it. Let it come to room temperature so it softens a bit and stir well before using.

Storage Tips

Refrigerate: Once the brownies have cooled completely, cover them with plastic wrap or foil, or cut them into squares and put them into an airtight container in a single layer or with parchment paper between layers. Refrigerate for up to a week.

Freeze: To store longer, freeze the brownies for up to 3 months in a freezer safe container.